Under the general heading of Inmates Running the Institution, how about the news this morning that there may be a ban on homework and classroom presentations imposed at the Toronto District School Board in the three to five days before exams begin.
You won’t be too shocked to learn that the proposal came from a student trustee. But the notion somehow got enough consideration to be recommended by the board’s program committee. Now input will be gathered before it goes on for consideration by the full board.
Wild guess: students will be overwhelmingly in favour; teachers will be strongly opposed; parents will be scratching their heads...again.
Whatever happened to letting professionals do their jobs? Do we have to mandate everything for everybody all the time?
The argument in favour of a work ban says that students are so busy studying right before exams that is unfair to ask them to complete major assignments.
Ted Kuhn, the student trustee who proposed the assignment holiday says that, “high school has become so stressful, that to have a major test or presentation (on) the days before an exam won’t help your exam performance or your love of learning.”
What it might well do is simulate conditions that Kuhn and his generation will face regularly in the work world after they graduate. Why wait to experience the pain?
While we all remember the stress of having teachers give deadlines for assignments within the same few days (don’t they ever co-ordinate?), this is one of those things you can generally file under “fact of life.”
We keep hearing complaints about the crowded curriculum and the difficulty teachers have in covering all of the material assigned in the time allotted.
Universities must provide remedial courses and seminars to teach material that was supposed to be covered in high school, but got missed in the continual curriculum squeeze.
If students really want some perspective on student stress, we could always arrange some student exchanges to Japan.
One Toronto school has already tried the moratorium for a while but dropped it this year. The reason? Students were skipping school in that last week to study.
If by any chance this whole homework avoidance strategy ruse works, we working stiffs should consider adapting it to our own needs.
We can demand that our employers provide no new assignments in the last two weeks of April, when we are burdened with the psychological trauma of trying to file our income tax forms.
We can demand that no presentations be required in the week before we go on vacation, lest the resulting stress spoil our pending state of serenity. Not to mention the dangers of post-holiday stress syndrome.
Strike up a program committee, run it by your student trustee and send it to your board. Then run like hell.
Comments (7)
***** The difference in opinion, stress or no stress in student's life is a matter of changed (Canadian) reality.
Canadians of previous generation (like John's parents) were hardworking, honest, intelligent, technologically advanced, great people who made Canada to a respected (by the world) and powerful nation. They also showed and helped many third-world nations how to prosper.
Unfortunately, they failed to teach their own children any of the 'good' qualities. The NEW REALITY: Even raising a family of their own became too stressful for them. As a result the population declined. The governments (created by John) made business-plans to woo and bring immigrants, to ensure the well being of the host aging-generation and for the comfortable future of the new-generation (students). Today, we have the expendable immigrants to handle the stress. What the new-generation needs today to ensure their success (in Canada, to get and hang on a job) is the identity (a pale-skin and fluency in English).
If the present off-the-school Canadians can enjoy 'life sans stress', why can not their children! (note: In Ontario, the retirement age has eliminated and you can still hang on your jobs with same designation and pay, until the staff from your funeral home throw you into the flames. Some underpaid young immigrant will do the actual stressful part of your job for you).
Considering this new reality, the stress and challenges in student's life is totally unnecessary!.
//Anthony McJackson//
Posted by Anthony | January 23, 2007 5:18 PM
Posted on January 23, 2007 17:18
If I vividly recall the post dramatic stress Mr. Harris pushed onto straight A student, Kimberly Rogers, it’s Ma and Pa Rate Payers that are scratching their heads wondering about juniors grades when the mandatory Social Assistance Reform Bill became the corner stone for suicides.
Pending from a PAGG Forum, March 23 2001, the Region of Peel decided to fund the theory that the $315 per day costs to feed off real prisoners was more lucrative than to have students breaking out of class rooms because they’d only get house arrest for good grades.
Kimberly’s been deceased for 4 years and we’ll never find out who's been stealing Mississauga’s property taxes.
Posted by Wayne Nagy | January 23, 2007 3:51 PM
Posted on January 23, 2007 15:51
Stress can be as exhausting as a good physical workout. Stress, like a good physical workout, can also be exhilarating.
I recall the stresses of my high school years with something of nostalgia. It is not that things were easier back then, it was our attitude towards the stress. I think the term originally used in the physical fitness industry, ‘No pain -No Gain’, sums it up nicely.
If everything were easy, where would be the fun? If all playing fields are level; what is the challenge in the game? Where would be the satisfaction in getting a difficult job done and done well and on time if anybody or even a robotic process could have accomplished the same thing?
Did I always succeed at everything I did in high school or the extracurricular activities I joined? No, not always, but more often than not I did very well. Did I feel at the end of a semester or school year that I had earned my holiday break? Yes I did because I and the majority of my fellow students had worked hard under much stress for long periods of time.
If you lower expectations you will lower results. To expect a break after a period of hard work under stress is reasonable. To expect a break before and after a period of work under stress; is, in my old fogy’s opinion, just plain ridiculous.
Picture what life for those no-stress-high-school-students would be like after graduation. What if one of them were to get a job, get married, have children and then, oh –my-god, they come home and had to make dinner. Could they handle the challenge; or would they go to bed hungry because they were too stressed?
Posted by Stephen Wahl | January 22, 2007 12:30 PM
Posted on January 22, 2007 12:30
Most of it’s just bashing the proverbial head against the concrete wall because of pooling and structural problems in the system in the first place. Even the regional Bachelor of Arts in Social Services, David Szwarc’s knows the biggest bucks in government business are those Welfare job search statements after a scholar can lob off student loans.
As I recall as a High School graduate, some 30 years ago, it might be better to bring a few pee shooters to council meetings just to keep these guys awake!
Posted by Abbe | January 20, 2007 8:13 AM
Posted on January 20, 2007 08:13
I'm not certain how helpful a ban would be for students.
When i was in high school (6 years ago) teachers were so tight on teaching time that they had to introduce new material right up to the last day.
The fact is if you students don't do the homework they won't learn the material and will be in trouble when it comes time to write the exam.
Posted by OJ | January 18, 2007 10:42 PM
Posted on January 18, 2007 22:42
Hey there, John,
I agree with crazyrabbits on this one if for no other reason that it goes a baby step to level the obscenely uneven playing field that highschool kids nowadays have to face.
I agree with all your points too. But to me, bottomline is a fairness thing.
Highschool students in an affluent area don't need to work and help out their families like some kids do.
So you got kids competing for university marks where the rich kids can do homework and study because that's all parents require of them.
I was lucky that way. My parents would tell me my only "job" was school.
Other kids weren't that lucky. I've seen kids doing homework on breaks in their fastfood jobs. Or study while working evenings too.
Yes, some kids work as a choice. They're not the ones I care about.
It's The Others. And they can use that break. Especially when the marks can mean whether they make it into university or not.
Toodles,
The Mississauga Muse
Posted by The Mississauga Muse | January 18, 2007 7:26 PM
Posted on January 18, 2007 19:26
As I recall, the last few weeks of high school (at least, when I was there) saw many people suffering from almost-breakdowns after being swamped with exams AND homework. If this can raise student marks and put less pressure on the teachers to scrounge for year-end assignments, I'm all for it.
Posted by crazyrabbits | January 18, 2007 3:28 PM
Posted on January 18, 2007 15:28